This...doesn't make sense. Alice doesn't lie to Carlisle, but this is -- No. Jasper with wincing of actual pain, Alice distraught, Edward closed off and --

No!

"No -- I would remember! How could I have been there so many centuries ago and not remember?" Carlisle's voice raises again to nearly a shout - unnecessary given both the proximity and the abilities of his children, but the shock of it. It's impossible.

Already Carlisle's brain is running through what he could have forgotten, overlooked, "I would remember -- "